Skip to main content

Use particle wa or ga in Japanese

The subtle distinction between Japanese particles は (wa) and が (ga) makes it difficult to choose between them. Here I will show you a simple way to get it right every time.

Professor Eleanor Jorden of Cornell University taught me that we actually have the same thing in spoken English. We stress words in a sentence to emphasize them. Consider:

"THIS is delicious"emphasizes that this one is the delicious one, as compared to others. In this situation you use が (ga);

これおいしい。    (Kore ga oishii.)

Be careful to offer kind words about the others so that nobody feels left out:

それも食べたいですね。    (Sore mo tabetai desu ne.)

"This is DELICIOUS" emphasizes the taste; the thing being tasted is already established. In this situation you use は (wa);

 これおいしい。    (Kore wa oishii.)

Since the thing that is delicious is clear, Japanese speakers commonly drop これは and just say, 

おいしい。   (Oishii.)

As demonstrated by the above examples, が (ga) emphasizes the word to which it is attached, and は (wa) de-emphasizes the word in favor of the rest of the sentence. Another way to tell the difference is to ask yourself which word you might repeat in colloquial speech:

  • これ、これおいしい!  (This one, this is delicious!) uses ga.
  • これおいしい!うまい!  (This is delicious! Tasty!) uses wa.

Interrogatives

Interrogatives like "which?", "what?" and "who?" can be followed by all kinds of particles and words, including が (ga), but never は (wa):

どれがおいしいか。   (Dore ga oishii ka.)

だれ…                      (Dare wa...) [Incorrect]

Returning to how we stress words in spoken English, one might say "WHICH is delicious?" In Japanese this calls for が (ga). We would never say, "Which is DELICIOUS?", which corresponds to the incorrect は (wa).

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Would You Like to Read a Removed Post?

You have been redirected to this page because you were looking for a post that I removed. From time to time I remove a post that I think is outdated, but I could be wrong. If you want to read a deleted post, please tell me by adding a comment to this post. Describe the article by telling me the title, URL or content. Thank you and sorry for the trouble.

The Reef Lounge

When I was about four, we vacationed at the Handerly Hotel & Resort in San Diego (formerly the Stardust Motor Hotel).  That place was heaven on earth as far as I was concerned. I loved the pool. Next to the pool there was a bar, and behind the bar was an underwater theater. It was here that I saw one of the most outlandish scenes I have ever witnessed.

Avoid the Virtual Kidnapping Scam

A relative recently fell victim to the virtual kidnapping scam, where criminals demand ransom for a loved one whom they only claim to have kidnapped.  To make their claim more convincing, the perpetrators make their ransom demand when the purported kidnapping victim cannot be contacted.  They might simply know when the person is isolated and unavailable, or they might force them to go incommunicado by stealing their mobile phone.